Many collectors and parents are often surprised to learn why off-centre cards affect grading scores and just how much card centring influences grading outcomes. Off‑centre cards typically receive lower grades because centring is a core criterion evaluated alongside surface, corners and edges. From the moment a card is inspected by PSA, Beckett or CGC, the three grading authorities Black Label Grading proudly partners with, any imbalance in centring can jeopardise a top score like Gem Mint 10. At Black Label Grading, we prioritise clarity and education, helping every submitter understand exactly why off-centre cards affect grading scores and how to avoid common pitfalls.
Table of Contents
How centring is measured and why it matters
Centring refers to the balance of spacing around a card’s design. A card with narrow borders on one side and wide borders on the other may be considered off‑centre, even if it’s factory-fresh. Grading companies apply specific measurements, like 60/40 or better on the front and 75/25 or better on the back, to determine whether a card meets their centring standards. When those limits are exceeded, even slightly, it directly impacts the card’s grade. This objective approach to centring is a key reason why off-centre cards affect grading scores across all major grading platforms.
Graders use tools like centring rulers or digital scanners to assess border symmetry with precision. Even a tiny deviation, something easily missed by the naked eye, can push a card below the thresholds required for top grades. That’s why a perfectly sharp and clean card can still end up with a lower score due to uneven borders.
Real‑world examples of centring’s impact
Imagine submitting a card that has immaculate surface quality, flawless corners and sharp edges, but the centring measures 65/35. In this case, no matter how well-preserved the rest of the card is, it’s unlikely to achieve a grade higher than Near Mint or Mint. This harsh reality often comes as a surprise, especially to newer collectors or parents sending in childhood cards. Understanding why off-centre cards affect grading scores can save you time, money, and disappointment.
At Black Label Grading, we frequently see cards that could have scored higher if only the centring had been slightly better. Beckett, for example, requires near-perfect 50/50 front and back centring to award a coveted “Black Label 10.” PSA and CGC also enforce strict guidelines for top grades, meaning that off‑centre cards, even when pack-fresh, often fall short of collectors’ expectations.
How to avoid submitting off‑centre cards
Preventing grading losses due to poor centring starts with proper card selection and review. While you can’t control how cards are printed, you can control what you send in for grading.
- Inspect your cards with centring tools
Use a centring gauge or a digital measuring app to check the border symmetry before submission. This simple step can help you filter out cards that fall outside acceptable limits. - Pre-screen with a critical eye
Cards that look “off” at a glance often are. Compare both horizontal and vertical border spacing to spot any inconsistencies. By doing this, you’ll quickly learn to recognise why off-centre cards affect grading scores before it’s too late. - Know your card sets
Some print runs are notorious for poor centring. If you’re collecting a set known for this issue, be extra cautious during your selection process. - Avoid trimming or altering cards
Alterations meant to “correct” centring usually backfire and may even lead to authentication failure. Authenticity always trumps perceived improvement.
By carefully assessing centring before submission, you significantly reduce the chance of a disappointing result, and develop a sharper eye for off‑centre cards.
The role of centring in resale value
Centring doesn’t just influence the grade, it directly affects a card’s resale potential. In today’s market, buyers often scrutinise centring before making high-value purchases, especially for modern cards expected to achieve Gem Mint or higher. Even a minor misalignment can result in lower offers or reduced buyer interest, regardless of how clean the rest of the card appears. Recognising why off-centre cards affect grading scores isn’t just about understanding grading, it’s about protecting the long-term value of your collection. By learning to spot centring flaws early, you give yourself a competitive edge in both grading and resale.
Why centring education matters at Black Label Grading
We believe that the more you know about grading criteria, the better your results will be. That’s why we go beyond simply submitting cards, we educate and support collectors throughout the process. Whether you’re a seasoned collector aiming for high-end investment pieces, or a parent just beginning to explore card grading, we take the time to explain concepts like why off‑centre cards affect grading scores in clear, practical terms.
When you work with Black Label Grading, you’re not left guessing. We analyse your cards thoroughly and provide honest feedback, so you can make smart grading choices. Many clients have thanked us for identifying centring issues early, saving them from paying for grades that wouldn’t reflect the card’s true potential.
Get in touch
Centring can make or break a card’s grade. Regardless of how pristine it looks otherwise. By understanding why off-centre cards affect grading scores, you equip yourself to make better submission decisions and maximise the value of your collection. At Black Label Grading, we combine expert insights, honest advice and thorough pre-grading services to help you succeed in the grading process.
Maximise your card’s potential with expert support. Submit through Black Label Grading and grade with confidence. If you have any more questions about grading, get in touch and we will be happy to answer them, or if you want to book to drop your cards off check out our website for more details.
